Style Showdown: Which Olsen Sis Is the Crazier Bag Lady?

Wed., Nov. 18, 2009 3:40 PM PST by Sydne Summer

In true twin fashion, Mary-Kate and Ashley Olsen carried matching Hermès Kelly bags to last night's MoMA Film Benefit honoring Tim Burton.

Their purses are classic. And the whole "I went digging through Grandma's closet" look is such an Olsen signature that it no longer shocks us. But from the neck up, the girls were just as eccentric as the Sweeney Todd director.

MK's dark lips and black hat were nothing compared to her sister's hair. Just check out Ashley's pastel streaks! And we always thought she was the classier of the two.

Who do you think picked a better outfit for the iconic purse? Vote in mystyle's Style Showdown gallery—then keep clicking to see how Ashley wore that fab leopard coat first!